by Barbara Radner
We've identified these texts as great options for text pairings based on similar themes, literary devices, topic, or writing style. Supplement your lesson with one or more of these options and challenge students to compare and contrast the texts. To assign a paired text, click on the text to go to its page and click the "Assign Text" button there.
The Worst SinJoshua Salik
How do we judge what is right and wrong? Are there some actions that are better or worse that others? These are just a few of the questions raised in this parable about the Jewish judgment day, Yom Kippur, by Joshua Salik.Pair “Honest Abe” with “The Worst Sin” and ask students to think about how the ideas of morality and goodness are taken up in each text. Why did people prize Lincoln’s honesty, compassion, and devotion to being fair to all? How does his willingness to take action to set things right differ from the nature of the man discussed at the end of the latter story? Do you think a person has to be as honest and actively committed to fairness as Lincoln was to be considered good?
Paul Revere's RideHenry Wadsworth Longfellow
The poem "Paul Revere's Ride" tells the story of Paul Revere, whose ride through greater Boston one night in 1775 helped spark the American Revolution.Pair “Honest Abe” with “Paul Revere’s Ride” and have students consider the historical context for each tale. What does the former text suggest about Lincoln’s leadership abilities? Do you think it implies that he was a good choice to lead the country during its identity crisis? What does the poem suggest about the historical backdrop of Lincoln’s presidency? Do you think the urgency of the time period demanded that someone with Lincoln’s moral compass act as a leader?
Columbus and the EggBarbara Radner
"Columbus and the Egg" retells a fabled story of how Columbus proved his accomplishments to his critics.Pair “Columbus and the Egg” and “Honest Abe” and ask students to discuss how short anecdotes about historical figures alter our views of these people. What lessons do these short pieces teach readers?
Professor Lowe's AdventureRobert Feeman
In "Professor Lowe's Adventure," a scientist prepares to fly his hot air balloon over the Atlantic Ocean in 1861.Pair “Honest Abe” with “Professor Lowe’s Adventure” and ask students to discuss Abraham Lincoln in both stories. After reading “Honest Abe,” are students surprised to hear that Lincoln used spies in the Civil War? Why or why not?
An Honest MistakeKaren Meissner
In "An Honest Mistake," a young girl learns an important lesson about telling the truth.Pair “Honest Abe” with “An Honest Mistake” and have students compare characters and their values. How did Abraham Lincoln get his nickname in “Honest Abe”? What do his actions show about what he valued? What do Karie’s actions in “An Honest Mistake” show about what she values? Why do you think that honesty is an important trait for people, like friends and leaders, to have?