Skip to main content

It's No One's Fault When It's Everyone's Fault

Shelby Ostergaard 2019 9th Grade Lexile: 1080

More than 18,000 people were packed outside Cincinnati’s Riverfront Coliseum on the evening of December 3, 1979. They were excited. They were there to see The Who, one of the biggest rock bands in the world. Every sold-out show the band held was greeted by crowds of screaming fans who rushed to get near the musicians. That night was no different. As the doors opened, fans could hear the band warming up. The crowd surged forward through the door, moving in human waves, crashing against the doors like the ocean hits rocks. There wasn’t enough room. But the crowd didn’t stop. Not even when people began getting crushed.

Eleven people died that night, trampled by the surge. Today, if you were to ask any of those fans whether a good spot to see their favorite band was worth a human life, it’s likely they would say no. So what were they thinking? Psychologists argue that they weren’t thinking at all, that each individual lost a sense of themselves and became part of a larger “hivemind,” a collective consciousness. Individuals didn’t kill those eleven victims that night; a crowd did. This process is known as deindividuation. 

What is deindividuation?            

Deindividuation, as the psychologist David Myers put it, is “doing together what you would not do alone.” It takes place when a person’s identity within a group overrides their own identity and self-awareness. In short, people lose their self-awareness in groups; they become less self-conscious and less inhibited. Once individuals shed their inhibitions, the actions of the group can get out of control. People can end up making decisions that encourage unity within the group but harm others outside of it. They start to feel the power of the crowd, lose their sense of right and wrong, and are carried along by the circumstances and their environment. In the crowd, the individual is gone. They see themselves as part of something bigger. “Everyone is doing it,” the individual tells themselves, and this gives them more justification for their behaviors. People in these situations often feel no sense of personal accountability. Blame is attributed to the group at large. It’s no one’s fault when it’s everyone’s fault.

In 1895, with the publication of The Crowd: A Study of the Popular Mind, the polymath Gustave LeBon described how the “unconscious action of crowds” is substituted for “the conscious activity of individuals.” He identified two important factors that are needed in order to create this substitution — anonymity and what’s come to be called diffused responsibility.

Anonymity

Anonymity is present because an individual can hide themselves and their acts within the larger group. Looking back at the crowd surge at the The Who concert, it is difficult for authorities to point out individuals or any individual acts that led to the eleven deaths. In a crowd that size, individuals are largely anonymous.

Here’s another example of the power of anonymity. In the 1970s, a group of psychologists used Halloween as a controlled study of how anonymity shapes our behavior. They picked out 27 homes in a Seattle neighborhood to use as makeshift laboratories. They wanted to see if being in a Halloween costume would affect the behavior of children. They placed a bowl of candy outside each home. Those young children who turned up to trick-or-treat at the residencies were told by an adult that they could only have one piece of candy each. The adult would then leave the children on the doorstep. Half the time, the adult would ask the children to say their names and where they lived before they left the children alone on the doorstep. The children were secretly monitored. If they arrived with adults they were excluded from the results. These were the findings: less than 10% of children who turned up alone and told the adult their name took more than one piece of candy. That number increased to 20% when they were alone and anonymous. In a group, 20% of those children who revealed their identity stole the candy. When it was an anonymous group of children, the result was significantly higher: 60%. The final conclusion was that the kids who felt both anonymous and protected by the group were the ones most likely to break the rule and take more candy. The experiment revealed how anonymity influences people to do things they wouldn’t normally do.

Diffused responsibility

Diffused responsibility works when the individual does not feel responsible for their actions. In the case of the The Who concert, it would not be surprising for individuals to feel as if it was not their fault — or at least not their fault alone. It’s likely they would argue that they were just doing what others were doing, and they were not the person who crushed one of the victims. Being in a group allows them to feel less responsible. The principles behind a firing squad work in the same way. When soldiers line up to execute someone by shooting, one or two soldiers are given a blank cartridge. None of the soldiers are told beforehand if they are using blank cartridges or live ammunition. All of the soldiers fire at the same time, and the blank cartridges reinforce the diffusion of responsibility. Soldiers can always tell themselves that they might have been the person who fired a blank round.

What does deindividuation look like? 

There are pro-social forms of deindividuation, like losing your inhibitions when dancing amongst a crowd or being part of a crowd caught up in suddenly looking for a missing child or pet. But unfortunately, it most often occurs in negative circumstances and situations. Rioting and mob justice are some of the most common examples of deindividuation.

Another environment in which deindividuation thrives is during hazing, the ritual act of putting someone through strenuous and often humiliating tasks as part of their training or initiation. In the case of college fraternities and sororities, for example, the people carrying out the hazing see themselves as one body. The people who are “pledging” — attempting to join the group — are viewed as being on the outside, trying to get in. In these circumstances, the Greek organization often puts the pledges through degrading and dangerous practices, as was the case with Timothy Piazza, a student at Penn State University, who fatally fell down the stairs at an initiation event while pledging a fraternity. It is alleged that the fraternity brothers forced Timothy to “consume life-threatening amounts of alcohol,” which caused him to fall. Many acts of hazing, which include beatings, forcing others into menial labor, force-feeding undesirable food, and public humiliation, would likely not be condoned by individuals in the group. But together, the individuals are swept up in the power and control they have over new members, as well as the anonymity the group affords them.

Our understanding of crowds and group behavior has grown since Gustave LeBon wrote in 1895, and though much of his work has been debunked, the fundamentals and factors that he set out remain. The larger the group, the more anonymous a person is, and the less responsible they feel for the group action. When both factors occur, individuals lose their sense of self-awareness and their fear of accountability. They start to simply follow the crowd. This has had huge consequences around the world. Lynchings, wartime atrocities, and genocidal massacres have all been carried out under the influence of deindividuation. Today is no different. Sports fans destroy cities after their team wins big. Groups get together and bully other people; online chat rooms, comment threads, and message boards are used to terrorize people.

It is easy to judge people for falling victim to deindividuation, and by no means should we condone negative behaviors that derive from it, but under the right conditions, we could all be subject to it. A strong desire to identify with a group can increase a person’s chances of deindividuation. Maybe something happens to us when we put a mask on at Halloween, when we’re in the stands expressing our fanatical loyalty to our sports team, or when we’re trolling someone on social media of whom we don’t approve — there are many circumstances that could leave us vulnerable. The best way to combat it might be to always keep in mind, when in group situations, how susceptible we are to groupthink, how both our anonymity and our environment play a part. The more we recognize this, the more likely we are to hold on to our personal accountability.

This might be just what’s truly required to stand out among the crowd.