How TikTok Changed Our Musical World
Nils Vanderlip was six years into his career as a professional musician when his band got an offer to sign with a record label. “It was a compelling pitch,” says Vanderlip, a keyboard player, guitarist, and producer for the band VHS Collection, which reached over 200 million streams on Spotify. “So we signed with them.”
The record company wanted to discuss a strategy for marketing the band’s music. “The first thing they said to us was ‘You guys need to be on TikTok,’” says Vanderlip. The company suggested posting daily videos to give fans a glimpse into band members’ lives.
“We weren’t crazy about the idea,” Vanderlip says. “We like the idea of having a certain amount of mystique.” So the band said no.
A few years later, Vanderlip left his career as a full-time musician. Even with a large fan base, the band still wasn’t making enough money to cover expenses, Vanderlip explains. His experience motivated him to establish Harmonic Future, a firm that invests in music technology companies to help artists earn more money for their work.
From Rock Clubs to Follower Counts
The story of Vanderlip’s band is a familiar one. It’s never been easy to make a living as a musician — unless you happen to be Taylor Swift, Bob Dylan, or the like. But TikTok has added a new wrinkle by changing how companies find and work with artists. As a result, the most successful artists today aren’t just good musicians; they’re also savvy social media influencers.
In the past, record labels had more employees who were responsible for finding new musical talent. They’d comb through artists’ submissions — called demo tapes — or visit small rock clubs and listen to bands in person. If they liked what they heard, they would sign the artists. “They would make the decision based on the quality of the music,” Vanderlip says.
But it takes a lot of money to launch a new musician’s career, and record labels have become less willing to take a financial risk on an unknown artist. Today, most companies look at an artist’s social media following — primarily on TikTok and Instagram — before even listening to their music. A large follower count indicates the artist has already done the leg work of finding and cultivating fans, making it easier for the record label to market to that audience.
If those follower counts aren’t high enough, the record label won’t even bother listening to the music, says Vanderlip. But if the social media following is strong, the company will take the next step to evaluate the music and decide whether to sign the person.
Going Viral — Then Burning Out?
While TikTok has been a frustrating obstacle for some artists, it’s been a game-changer for others, elevating their songs from mostly unknown to wildly popular. When someone publishes content on the platform, users can interact with it immediately, often creating their own video clips featuring the song. This ongoing interaction between fans and artists has a powerful impact on a song’s success; it can even provide the spark to launch an artist’s career. For instance, Lil Nas X rocketed to fame in 2019 when his song “Old Town Road” went viral on TikTok.
Still, being a social media superstar has drawbacks, especially if social media isn’t your full-time job. Artists may feel compelled to constantly create fresh content to avoid losing fans. Research indicates that to engage the most followers, the best length for a TikTok clip is between 15 and 60 seconds. Yet creating those short videos is a lot of work. An artist might spend several hours producing and editing a one-minute clip. And producing such content requires a specific skill set — one that often has little to do with being a competent musician.
In a 2022 story for NPR, Damoyee, a musician from Dallas, Texas, shared that the pressure of creating social media content negatively affected her mental health. She decided to take a break from posting to focus on school and other commitments.
TikTok’s Uncertain Future
There’s no denying that TikTok has had a massive influence on musical culture. And some people are concerned the platform has grown too powerful. In 2024, Universal Music Group (UMG), which has represented artists such as Billie Eilish and Harry Styles, pulled millions of songs from the platform. They did so with claims that artists weren’t being compensated fairly for their work. UMG also stated that AI-generated recordings on TikTok could be devaluing songwriters’ authenticity.
In the same year, the U.S. government, concerned about the political influence of TikTok’s Chinese parent company ByteDance, enacted the Protecting Americans from Foreign Adversary Controlled Applications Act, signed by President Joe Biden. The law required ByteDance to sell the platform within several months or face a nationwide ban in the U.S. if no sale occurred.
After legal challenges, the Supreme Court upheld the law in 2025. When the deadline arrived in January 2025, TikTok briefly went offline in the U.S. as negotiations continued. In December 2025, ByteDance agreed to sell TikTok’s U.S. operations to American investors. The deal was finalized in January 2026, and will allow the platform to continue operating in the U.S.
Whether TikTok’s status in the U.S. faces any renewed challenges remains to be seen. But the platform’s wide-reaching impact is a reminder that what becomes popular in our musical world is often determined by much more than the song itself. When artists post videos to show what they had for breakfast or to demonstrate the latest TikTok dance, for instance, “it’s not related to the creative musical aspect of it,” says Vanderlip. “It’s more, they’re playing the game of social media.”