The American Criminal Justice System
Landmark Supreme Court decisions. Millions of incarcerated Americans. Thousands of citizens protesting in the streets. The United States criminal justice system impacts the life of every person in America. With a basis in the Constitution and Bill of Rights, an idealistic but deeply imperfect beginning, and involvement in many controversial issues today, the justice system trifecta of law enforcement, courts, and corrections has a hugely consequential role in our society.
The Origins Of The American Criminal Justice System
Miscarriages of justice were rampant in the beginnings of our fledgling nation. The colonies were ruled by King George III of England and were forced to follow edicts issued by their faraway ruler. The colonists felt that they were the victims of an unbalanced and disorganized justice system. For example, British “Writs of Assistance” allowed illegal searches of colonial homes and also legalized the seizure of private property for use by the British government. George III eliminated trial juries in the colonies. Appointed judges were British officials who were only loyal to the King, not the individuals and communities which were impacted by their decisions.
Anger over these issues, and many others, eventually erupted into the Revolutionary War, the creation of the Constitution, and the later addition of the Bill of Rights. Within the ten amendments that make up the Bill of Rights, the Framers enshrined certain principles in an attempt to form a justice system that would ensure fair treatment for American citizens.
Amendments 4-8 deal specifically with criminal justice and the rights of the accused.
Amendment 4 ensures protection from unreasonable searches and seizures by stating “the right of people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects…and no warrants shall issue but upon probable cause.”
Amendment 5 states that no American will be “deprived of life, liberty, or property without due process of the law.” This is why an elaborate justice system exists throughout our country: in order to ensure “due process” for individuals.
Amendment 6 concerns the rights of accused people in criminal cases. It not only gives Americans “the right to a speedy and public trial by an impartial jury”, but also states that people will “have the assistance of counsel”. All people accused of a crime have a right to a lawyer. If they cannot afford to hire a lawyer, the government will provide a lawyer for them. These lawyers are called public defenders.
Amendment 8 is about punishment or sentencing. The amendment declares “excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted.” The final phrase of the amendment has been controversial and litigated throughout our history, most notably in cases where the punishment involves the death penalty.
Sadly, when the Bill of Rights was written, the legal rights outlined in the amendments only applied to a small fraction of people living in America: white male property owners. Women, enslaved people, Native Americans, and many others were not protected by these amendments and were victims of an imperfect and, at times, pernicious justice system. Since the Bill of Rights was ratified in 1789, it has been an ongoing struggle for all Americans to equally access these rights to which every citizen is entitled. Social justice movements and historical events such as the Civil War, the women’s rights movement, and the civil rights movement have resulted in additional amendments to our Constitution concerning the rights of all citizens. However, many Americans would argue that our justice system is still deeply flawed today in regards to fair treatment for all members of our society. Part of that problem stems from the enormity of the justice system itself.
United States Criminal Justice System Part I: Law Enforcement
The criminal justice system that originated with the amendments in the Bill of Rights now has three modern components. The first is law enforcement. There are law enforcement officers and departments in every arena of American life, from park rangers to small town police forces to federal agencies like the Federal Bureau of Investigation.
Law enforcement is a vast and complex system because there is an enormous amount of laws in our country. Every year, new laws are introduced by elected officials and current laws are tweaked. At the national level, thousands of statutes and regulations codify our laws. In addition to federal laws, states have their own sets of statutes and regulations for issues and topics that have been left to states to regulate. Furthermore, when judges make rulings, their rulings set a precedent, meaning that these decisions can be binding or persuasive in subsequent cases. When a similar situation comes before a judge, they are guided by how previous cases in their jurisdiction were decided. Due to the complex tangle of laws at all levels of American society, the law enforcement branch of the justice system is immense.
According to the 2008 Bureau of Justice Statistics, there are approximately 1.1 million local and state law enforcement employees throughout the United States. In addition, there are 73 separate federal departments that employ about 120,000 law enforcement officers, the largest being the Department of Homeland Security and the Department of Justice.
Law enforcement officers wield enormous power, because they have legal power to enforce all laws, write citations, arrest people, and use deadly force. Unfortunately, that power has been abused by individuals throughout the history of our justice system. Recently, the Black Lives Matter movement arose from anger over black men and women being killed by law enforcement officers.
United States Criminal Justice System Part II: Courts
The second component of the United States justice system is the courts. The court system is responsible for operation of all legal cases and trials brought by law enforcement. Just as with law enforcement, there are several levels of courts within the justice system. On the state level, these include trial courts, civil courts, and state supreme courts. Federal courts include district courts, appellate courts for hearing appeals, and the highest court in the United States: the federal Supreme Court.
All criminal courts, no matter the level, have lawyers and judges. Lawyers argue for either the defendant (the person or entity accused of a crime) or the state. Defendants can be individuals, groups, or corporations. Lawyers often specialize in a type of law—for example, criminal law—and only work on those cases. Judges preside over a courtroom. They listen to the arguments for each side, keep order in the court, and often decide the outcome of a court case and a sentencing. Judges are either elected or appointed.
Some courts have a jury, but despite the popular depiction of courtrooms in television and movies, the vast majority of court cases do not make it to a jury trial. Whether or not a jury is required depends on a variety of factors, including the type of crime, negotiations between the lawyers ahead of a trial, and the potential sentence faced by the defendant. In keeping with the language of the Sixth Amendment of the Bill of Rights, if a jury is needed, it must be made up of regular citizens who are called to jury duty. To be selected for a jury, people must go through a screening process to ensure they can be impartial and fair during the trial.
If a criminal case makes it to a trial, the defendant is pronounced either guilty or innocent of the charges by the judge or the jury. In some rare cases, a trial may be dismissed or result in a “hung” jury: meaning the jury could not come to a unanimous decision. This means that the case can be retried. If a person is judged guilty of a crime, several things can happen. One option is that the defendant, along with their lawyer, can appeal their case to a special court called a Court of Appeals. This is often how famous cases make their way to the Supreme Court: the lawyer and the defendant keep challenging the decisions of lower courts and the case is then selected to be heard by the Supreme Court. Before a defendant can appeal, however, they are sentenced by a judge or jury. Sentencing for crimes varies widely depending on the place where the crime occurred, the criminal record of the convicted person, the severity of the crime, and the discretion of the judge or jury. Sentences can be as insignificant as a small fine, and as severe as life in prison or capital punishment. Judges have guidelines on how to sentence each crime, but they also have wiggle room to give the punishments they feel that each defendant deserves.
Unfortunately, in many historical cases, the court system has not been a body of justice, but an institution that reflects wider patterns of inequality in American society. Betts v. Brady, a case that came before the Supreme Court in 1942, is one example. Although the Sixth Amendment gave individuals the right to an attorney in federal cases, states were not required to provide representation to most defendants. Smith Betts was indicted on charges of robbery, but his request for an attorney was denied. The trial court convicted him of robbery. He appealed his conviction all the way up to the Supreme Court on the basis that he did not receive the assistance of counsel, but six of the nine Justices agreed that he was not entitled to an attorney, and Betts’ conviction was upheld. Justice Hugo Black, one of the three dissenting Justices, wrote that this practice is not in line with the court’s ideals of fairness. Defendants who could not afford an attorney were much more likely to be convicted. Years later, in 1963, the Supreme Court overturned the Betts v. Brady case decision in Gideon v. Wainwright, making it a requirement that all criminal defendants be provided with an attorney, even if they cannot afford one.
United States Justice System Part III: Corrections
The final component of the criminal justice system is corrections. The departments and employees in corrections are charged with supervising people who have been found guilty of a crime and have been given a sentence. People in corrections include probation officers, parole officers, and people who work in jails and prisons.
A major responsibility of the corrections arm of the justice system is incarceration. People in the United States can be held in jails before their court trial. If a person is found guilty of a crime, they may be sentenced to time in a variety of state or federal prisons, including juvenile prisons for kids, psychiatric prisons, military prisons, or high-security prisons. According to the World Prison Brief published by the Institute for Criminal Policy Research, in 2016 there were approximately 2.1 million incarcerated people in the United States of America. This number is not only the highest total population of imprisoned people of any country in the world, but is also the highest rate of imprisonment of any country in the world. For every 100,000 Americans, there are on average 655 people behind bars. Furthermore, minority Americans are incarcerated at a much higher rate than white Americans.
Eleanor Roosevelt said, “Justice cannot be for one side alone: it must be for both.” In a perfect America, the idea of justice and fairness is interpreted strictly through the lens of the Constitution, with every American receiving the legal protections outlined in Amendments 4-8. However, throughout our history, justice has often been decided based on discriminatory ideas and societal practices concerning race, class, gender, ethnicity, sexual orientation, immigration status, religion, political affiliation, and socioeconomic status. In other words, often justice was and continues to be for one side alone. The immensity of our justice system has many parts, involves a diverse group of people, and is constantly evolving. Today, elected officials, social-justice groups, and average Americans continue to monitor and petition for change in the practices of the entire system to strive for the American ideal: justice for all.