The Late Troubles at Salem
By the end of September 1692, 20 people in Massachusetts Bay were dead by order of the Court of Oyer and Terminer. While Chief Justice William Stoughton had no regrets and appeared determined to continue the witch-hunts, other men had grown uneasy. A few prominent people began to express their concerns publicly.
The Reverend Increase Mather, a well-respected and influential Boston minister, became alarmed at the court’s process. While Mather did not question the existence of witches, he wondered if innocent people were being put to death. On October 3, an essay he had recently completed, Cases of Conscience, was shared with other Boston ministers. It questioned relying exclusively on spectral evidence to convict a person of witchcraft. He cautioned, “[I]t were better that ten suspected witches should escape than one innocent person should be condemned.”
The Reverend Samuel Willard, another influential Boston minister, also tried to silence the witchcraft hysteria. He had spoken publicly against the unjust trials. He wrote a fictitious argument between two men, one from Boston and one from Salem. In it, he pointed out the irony of the situation in Salem: If a person confessed to being a witch, he or she survived, but if a person claimed innocence and denied being a witch, he or she was tried, found guilty, and executed.
Also in early October, Thomas Brattle, a well-known scientist and Boston merchant, wrote a letter that offered a description of what was taking place in Massachusetts Bay. The letter was copied and shared in Boston. In it, Brattle condemned the methods that the court had been using in the trials. He too believed that spectral evidence should not have been allowed, and he was scornful of how the “bewitched” girls had been treated as visionaries. Pointing out how families had been ruined by the court’s irresponsible pursuit of witches, he wondered if people would someday “not look upon these things without the greatest of sorrow and grief imaginable.”
The growing public unease pushed Governor William Phips to take action. He dissolved the Court of Oyer and Terminer on October 29, 1692. More than 100 people accused of witchcraft remained in jail, however. Phips ordered a new court — the Superior Court of Judicature — to conduct the remaining trials. Spectral evidence was not allowed in those proceedings. All but three people were acquitted, and Phips eventually pardoned those three people in May 1693. But while some people seemed to wrestle with feelings of guilt and remorse, there remained a general refusal to acknowledge what had taken place.
Thomas Maule was a Quaker and a Salem Town resident who took issue with the Puritans’ handling of the trials. He compared it to their persecution of Quakers. In 1695, he wrote Truth Held Forth and Maintained. It claimed that God would condemn the leaders of the Court of Oyer and Terminer for putting innocent people to death. Maule was arrested for slander and blasphemy. He spent a year in jail before being tried, but the jury refused to find him guilty.
On January 14, 1697, Massachusetts declared a day of fasting and prayer as a public acknowledgement and apology before God and the community of the great wrong that had been committed. Samuel Sewall alone publicly apologized for his part in the trials as a justice in the Court of Oyer and Terminer. Sewall stood up in front of the Boston congregation as his minister read his note of apology. Sewall accepted “the blame and shame” of the witch trials court. Guilt also seemed to motivate about a dozen jurors from the trials, who also came forward to ask God’s forgiveness.
Only one of the “bewitched” girls ever publicly apologized. Twelve-year-old Ann Putnam Jr. had testified against all but two of the people who were hanged. In August 1706, as she prepared to formally join a Puritan congregation, she asked for forgiveness for her role in taking the lives of innocent people, blaming the Devil for her actions.
Although some restitution was eventually made to the families of the executed and accused, the damage to lives was far reaching. Most of the accused people discovered that their personal property had been confiscated while they waited in prison for a trial. Once they were freed, they went back to living with neighbors, or in some cases with family members, who had accused them of being witches.