Skip to main content

The South Secedes

USHistory.org 2016 10th Grade Lexile: 1130

When Abraham Lincoln was declared the winner of the Presidential Election of 1860, South Carolina politicians were actually thrilled. During the presidential election, state legislators in South Carolina did not cast a single vote for the northern Republican leader. South Carolina, like every other southern state, had cast all of its electoral votes for Vice President John Breckenridge. Leaders in Charleston, South Carolina knew that the election would directly lead to the formation of a new nation.

The force of events moved very quickly upon the election of Lincoln. Within a few days, the two United States Senators from South Carolina submitted their resignations. South Carolina called for a convention to secede, or remove themselves from the Union.

Congress scrambled to prevent South Carolina from seceding. On December 18, Senator John J. Crittenden of Kentucky proposed the Crittenden Compromise. The compromise would amend the Constitution and extend the old Missouri Compromise line all the way to the Pacific Coast. Only, under this new compromise, all territory North of the line would be forever free, and all territory south of the line would have slavery protected by the federal government. While southern states liked the proposal, Republicans refused to accept it.

On December 20, 1860, by a vote of 169-0, the South Carolina legislature approved an "ordinance of secession," stating that "the union now subsisting between South Carolina and other States, under the name of 'The United States of America,' is hereby dissolved."

The Charleston Mercury newspaper said of the ordinance, "The tea has been thrown overboard, the revolution of 1860 has been initiated."

South Carolina's action resulted in conventions in other southern states. Mississippi, Florida, Alabama, Georgia, Louisiana, and Texas all left the Union by February 1. On February 4, delegates from all these states except Texas met in Montgomery, Alabama, to create and staff a government called the Confederate States of America. The Confederacy elected Jefferson Davis of Mississippi as their new president.

Throughout the secession crisis of 1860-1861, Abraham Lincoln was not yet president. He would not be inaugurated until March 4. President James Buchanan presided over the exodus from the Union. Although he thought secession to be illegal, he found using the army in this case to be unconstitutional. Both the North and the South awaited the arrival of President Lincoln and wondered anxiously what he would do.

Meanwhile, in South Carolina, the groundwork was being laid for the first actual battle of the Civil War. Six days after that state declared its ordinance of secession, 85 Union troops stationed in Charleston, South Carolina, withdrew to Fort Sumter, an island in Charleston Harbor. The North considered the fort to be the property of the United States government. By the time that the Confederate States of America formed, however, the people of South Carolina believed that the fort belonged to the new Confederacy.

The commander at Fort Sumter was Major Robert Anderson, a former slave owner who was nevertheless unquestionably loyal to the Union. With 6,000 South Carolina militia members circling the harbor, Anderson and his soldiers were cut off from reinforcements and resupplies. In January 1861, as one of the last acts of his administration, President Buchanan sent 200 soldiers and supplies on an unarmed merchant vessel, Star of the West, to reinforce Anderson. It quickly departed when South Carolina artillery started firing on it.

After Davis’ and Lincoln’s inaugurations, pressure mounted for the two new leaders to take some action on Fort Sumter. Lincoln in particular was pressured to reunite the states. The Union president thought that the southern secession was “artificial.” When Jefferson Davis sent a group to Washington to negotiate for the transfer of Fort Sumter to South Carolina, they were promptly refused.

Lincoln had a dilemma. Fort Sumter was running out of supplies, but any attack on the South Carolina militias cutting off the fort from resupplies would appear as Northern aggression. States that still remained part of the Union (such as Virginia and North Carolina) might be driven into the secessionist camp if they thought that the Union soldiers were the aggressors. People at home and abroad might become sympathetic to the South. But Lincoln could not allow his troops to starve, nor could they surrender and risk showing considerable weakness.

At last he developed a plan. On April 6, Lincoln told the governor of South Carolina that he was going to send provisions to Fort Sumter. He would send no arms, troops, or ammunition — unless, of course, South Carolina attacked.

Now the dilemma sat with Jefferson Davis. Attacking Lincoln's resupply ships would make the South the aggressive party. But he simply could not allow the fort to be resupplied — a southern newspaper writer warned, "Unless you sprinkle the blood in the face of the people of Alabama, they will be back in the old Union in less than ten days."

Davis decided he had no choice but to order Anderson to surrender Sumter. Anderson refused.

The Civil War began at 4:30 a.m. on April 12, 1861, when Confederate artillery, under the command of General Pierre Gustave T. Beauregard, opened fire on Fort Sumter. Confederate batteries showered the fort with over 3,000 shells in a three-and-a-half day period. Anderson surrendered before any men were killed. Ironically, Beauregard had developed his military skills under Anderson's instruction at West Point. This was the first of countless relationships and families devastated in the Civil War.

Though the Battle of Fort Sumter was technically a defeat for the Union, Lincoln got what he wanted – for the South to fire the first shot. After Sumter, Lincoln called for 75,000 volunteers to suppress the rebellion. Despite Lincoln’s best efforts though, four more states – Virginia, North Carolina, Tennessee, and Arkansas – seceded and joined the Confederacy. The Civil War had begun.